Thursday, December 9, 2010

Chain Bookstores going under?

One can only hope.

I made a comment recently along that line and of course many replied that I must be insane to wish that such a thing would happen. I did express concern about employees who would lose jobs but they should easily be able to find work at Independent bookstores that would flourish in the aftermath.

To understand my thinking one must understand the facts surrounding the publishing industry. Once upon a time all there was in the world were large publishing houses. Bookstores were a way for these houses to get their very large number of books to the public. Large publishers also used these chain bookstores to help warehouse all the books they had to print. You see, back in the day it was expensive to print books and publishers had to print A LOT of books at a time to justify the cost.

Come around to today and what we have are tons of Small QUALITY Publishing houses. There are Independent bookstores who showcase these talents but as you well know they are few and far between. Clearly, these small publishing houses would do much better IF they could get into these chain bookstores but that just isn't happening. Chain bookstores are more or less owned by large publishing houses and why would large publishing houses do anything to benefit their competition (or threat thereof.)

And that is why I could care less whether chain bookstores survive. They don't support small press authors and their attempts are feeble at best. Sort of like letting a cat participate in a dog show. They won't ever come around because they are pretty much in existence for the large publishing houses anyway (remember that used to be all there was.)

So let them go under. Independent bookstores are quite capable of filling the gaps left. You also have to keep in mind that a lot of best-selling authors have left the gravy train line (because the gravy was too thin) to self-publish. These authors can't even get into the chain stores so you readers are actually missing out on more quality fiction than you'd think you'd lose if chain bookstores fell under the weight of not supporting ALL quality fiction.

Of course you don't have to agree with me. I don't expect you to. Just like folks to understand why I don't care if chain bookstores meet their demise. It won't hurt my book sales at all or any other small press publisher.

Large publishers aren't the only ones in the game anymore. Not by a long shot.

Christian Chain Bookstores going under?

Well, since we're on a roll, the same logic applies here. Christian Chain Bookstores are even worse. Not only were they created to support ONLY publishers who pay a fee to belong to CBA or the Christian Booksellers Association, an Association formed to make sure all books put out by member publishers met strict and specific evangelical guidelines decided by them, they also say nay, nay to ANY other publisher large or small who isn't a paying member.

And yet their books find their way into chain bookstores due to the fact that larger publishers added CBA houses as imprints. So they get a double whammy from me. Can't wait to see these guys go because I've given up on them ever coming around. It would be an easy fix for them too. All chain Christian bookstores would have to do would be to state what kind of bookstore they are or allow all publishers who provide work that doesn't offend Christian readers of all faiths or at least most to come in. They've made no move to do either. So bye-bye to them. And yep, there are Independent Christian bookstores that treat all books by all publishers equally, affiliated or not. ;)

4 comments:

  1. Ouch. I understand your concern about wanting large bookstores to help small press authors-- and don't get me wrong, I'm no expert over here. I'm curious though, although you believe indie bookstores would "pick up the slack" as you put it, are you saying that the larger pub authors who DO have books in these stores would go under as well? Or would they be able to sell their work in the indie stores?(That would kind of dupe the term "indie" then, now wouldn't it lol.)

    The problem I have with seeing the larger stores suffer is that regardless of whether small pub authors can get their work in them or not, I wouldn't want to see even the larger pub authors suffer from the loss of sales. The way I see it is, as a whole, we should want the entire writing community to succeed and flourish...even if their world doesn't help ours. Am I making any sense?

    I understand it comes down to money, etc. but I just wouldn't want to rejoice at even larger pub authors losing sales or running out of avenues in which to sell their work-- even if they have it easier than I do. I'm just happy to see them succeed.

    Thoughts?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thank you Andrea. ;D

    And Rachael you have demonstrated the hope that chain bookstores are holding onto; that it's okay for one group of publishers to reign terror over another EQUALLY qualified group of publishers.

    In my "once upon a perfect world" scenario, chain stores wouldn't actually disappear. They'd just restructure and become LIKE Indie stores MEANING that bookstores would actually represent ALL publishers and not just the ones who everyone knows (and the ones who pay bookstores salaries more or less) because they've been around since Methuselah's time and were the only publishers out there once upon a golden age.

    You absolutely must understand that chain bookstores only represent large publishers period. Independent bookstores represent ALL publishers EQUALLY and recognize that being around longer doesn't mean better quality. Not by a long shot.

    Perhaps I need to reword my post a little because no, I don't think any publisher should sink. But neither do I think that chain bookstores should continue to operate if they don't work to find a way to accommodate all publishers.

    Too bad if they don't work to fix this and they go under and all the large houses sink because their bookstores are gone. That's all I'm saying. Finally the playing field will be level.

    Big publishers aren't going anywhere. My GORSH, anyone that can put out some of the work they put out and have it sell the way it sells has little to fear. Don't you think?

    But don't worry, chain bookstores aren't going anywhere and they aren't going to humor small press authors and things will just continue like they do now because as Bill Murray says in Meatballs, "the really good looking girls will still go out with the guys from Camp Mohawk cuz' they've got all the money. It just doesn't matter if we win or if we lose . . . it just doesn't matter. . . "

    But thank-you Rachel for pushing me to clarify.

    Love you girl!

    ReplyDelete
  3. I see where you are coming from now. I just really want to understand all of this hoopla haha. I for one adore indie stores and find them wherever I go, and I think what you just stated about them is what appeals to readers and small publishers alike. They are inclusive, and their support is tremendous compared to what small pub authors seem to have to put up with when it comes to the larger stores.

    Thanks for clarifying, keep the posts coming. Great discussion starters, and lots of good stuff to learn here.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I guess I just don't care. We don't even HAVE indie bookstores in my city. They got eaten alive a long time ago.

    I browse in B&N on rare occasions, but I almost never buy from there. I go home and add things to my Amazon wishlist or I go to the library. The only time I buy at B&N is if I'm in a time crunch and HAVE to have something immediately (like for a school assignment).

    I will be happy when eBooks become standard and people only buy paper books for toddlers or as keepsakes of a few special books. Save the trees and stop the warehousing and waste and the whole insane return policy crap. Pay the CREATORS, not the leeches. As for the brick and mortar stores? *shrug* "It just doesn't matter."

    ReplyDelete